Pizza Pan

Enjoy delicious stromboli, buffalo chicken pizza, ribs, and more at Pizza Pan in Youngstown. Open late with friendly staff, quick pickup, and mouthwatering pies. Call +1 330-270-9988!

Welcome to Pizza Pan

Signature Dining Experience

Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan

Pizza Pan greets you with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked pies and inviting flavors. Located at 4218 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH, this pizza haven opens its doors to pizza lovers day and night. The restaurant is renowned for its friendly staff and cozy atmosphere. Whether you’re craving a classic slice, a unique stromboli, or fall-off-the-bone ribs, Pizza Pan has it all. Stepping inside, you experience a family-oriented vibe that keeps guests coming back. Late-night cravings? Pizza Pan serves until the early hours, ensuring everyone leaves happy and satisfied.

Location & Contact

Address

4218 Mahoning Ave, Youngstown, OH 44515, United States

Phone

+1 330-270-9988

Social Media

About

Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan
Pizza Pan

Pizza Pan is the embodiment of culinary joy in Youngstown, Ohio. This family-oriented restaurant prides itself on serving up comfort food that brings people together. Owned by passionate pizza enthusiasts, it operates tirelessly to bring high-quality meals to the community. The menu boasts an array of options that cater to various tastes—from casual eaters to avid foodies. Specialty pizzas like The UltiMEATum Pizza cater to meat-lovers, while the Pepperoni Supreme Pizza appeals to traditionalists. Pizzas come in multiple sizes, accommodating small gatherings or larger celebrations alike.

Strombolis provide a delicious twist, making them a sought-after choice for those in the mood for something different. With a variety of appetizers and traditional chicken wings on the menu, there’s a little something for everyone.

The average price per meal hovers around $16.17, making it accessible for families and friends. Regular events on weekends and themed nights keep the spirit lively, drawing both locals and visitors. Another highlight? The restaurant opens late, ensuring night owls can satisfy their cravings.

Parking is plentiful, making your visit smooth and hassle-free. The location itself sits near local attractions, making it a convenient stop for those exploring Youngstown. Many patrons rave about the kind staff, enhancing the community feel at Pizza Pan, capturing the essence of a welcoming dining experience.

Work Hours

  • Sunday4 PM-2 AM
  • Monday4 PM-2 AM
  • Tuesday4 PM-2 AM
  • Wednesday4 PM-2 AM
  • Thursday4 PM-2 AM
  • Friday4 PM-2 AM
  • Saturday4 PM-2 AM

At Pizza Pan, the menu is diverse enough to cater to all appetites. Signature pizzas like the Chicken Bacon Ranch and Buffalo Chicken are fan favorites. For a hearty meal, dive into the BBQ Baby Back Ribs, a perfect balance of smokiness and tenderness. Need something to grab on the go? The strombolis offer convenience without sacrificing flavor. The restaurant offers dine-in and pickup options to fit everyone’s schedule.

It's worth noting that this spot gets quite popular during peak hours, especially Wednesday nights. For the best experience, plan your visit to avoid the rush. Plus, enjoy the warm atmosphere brought by the kind staff, making every meal a little brighter.

Pizza Pan

Pizza Pan features a charming exterior that draws you in with its vibrant signage and inviting facade. The outdoor seating option provides a relaxed environment, perfect for enjoying a meal with family or friends on a warm evening. Patrons often gather outside, sharing laughter and enjoying delicious food in the fresh air. The vibe is casual yet lively, making it an ideal spot for a laid-back dinner or a quick bite. Walking up to the restaurant, you're welcomed by the smell of freshly baked goods wafting through the air, setting the stage for a satisfying experience.

Customer Reviews

I was out dashing and stopped at this spot....the pizza smelled amazing. So my friend and I called them to ask if I could bring in some turkey pepperoni could he make us a pizza! He made the BEST pizza ever in under 10 minutes!!! It reminded us of the early 2000s Chuckie Cheese Pizza that I miss! Even brought it to our car along with some minute maid drinks! This is a hole in the wall spot! The dough is so light and fresh and each slice had its own pepperoni which I liked instead of it scattered across....the sauce was so fresh also! I'm already going back today!!!!!

t
therealjuju

My boy definitely deserves 5+ stars! He goes above and beyond for his customers. My cousin introduced me to pizza pan and it really has a similar taste to chucky cheese pizza-- I will always support this business, the pizza is always good!! He also has other food options that you can inquire about. Thank you for your service. XOXO

D
De'Asia D.

Another local awesome pizza place to go to, the cashier and baker were very nice...I ordered a medium cheese, they didn't have that dough made yet because it's in house dough so he used a large for the same price... The cheese and dough was awesome and the sauce had a very good sweet basil taste to it!!!! Very appreciated and a great price thanks!!!!

P
Pete J.

Delicious and fresh. Owner is very nice!

A
Audri

Always 1 nice fella making the orders, no fuss, just handmade . He'll bring your food 2 your , , , ! ONLY place to get a LATE in both counties past 12am! USUALLY OPEN UNTIL 2-3am. Pickup or delivery only from DoorDash, maybe GrubHub.

H
Heather B.

This place has amazing pizza definitely delicious nice crispy crust lots of flavor

M
Mary 1.